The Impact of Poor Management on Employee Retention

Employee retention is a critical issue for organizations globally, but it takes on a unique urgency in the African context, particularly in Kenya. In the United States, a LinkedIn workforce survey highlights that seven out of ten employees are likely to leave an organization if they encounter poor management.

While similar comprehensive data may be lacking in Africa, the increasing unrest among the youth regarding governance and leadership within organizations suggests that this trend is not limited to Western countries. Understanding the key behaviours that drive employees to quit and implementing strategies to mitigate these issues is essential for African organizations aiming to retain top talent.
Four Key Behaviors that Drive Employees to Quit
- Micromanagement and Lack of Autonomy: Micromanagement is one of the most detrimental behaviours a manager can exhibit. It stifles creativity, undermines employee confidence, and signals a lack of trust in the team’s capabilities. When employees feel that their every move is being watched and controlled, they become disengaged and demotivated. Over time, this leads to burnout and a desire to seek employment where their skills and judgment are trusted and valued.
- Poor Communication and Lack of Feedback: Communication is the cornerstone of effective management. When managers fail to communicate clearly, consistently, and transparently, employees are left in the dark about expectations, organizational goals, and their own performance. Moreover, a lack of constructive feedback denies employees the opportunity to grow and improve. When communication is inadequate, employees often feel undervalued and confused, leading to frustration and eventually resignation.
- Inconsistent or Unfair Treatment: Perceived fairness and equity in the workplace are critical to employee satisfaction. When managers show favoritism, apply policies inconsistently, or engage in discriminatory practices, it erodes trust and morale within the team. Employees are more likely to quit when they believe that they are being treated unfairly, especially if they see others receiving preferential treatment without merit.
- Lack of Career Development Opportunities: Employees are increasingly seeking opportunities for professional growth and advancement. When managers do not provide or support opportunities for learning, skill development, and career progression, employees may feel that they have reached a dead end in their current role. This stagnation can prompt them to seek out organizations that are more invested in their long-term career goals.
Strategies for HR Teams to Help Leaders Improve
To address these challenges and reduce employee attrition, Human Resource (HR) teams must play a proactive role in developing and supporting effective leadership within organizations. Here are some strategies that can help:
- Leadership Development Programs: HR should design and implement comprehensive leadership development programs that focus on building the skills necessary for effective management. This includes training on emotional intelligence, conflict resolution, communication, and decision-making. By equipping leaders with the right tools, organizations can create a more supportive and empowering work environment.
- 360-Degree Feedback Systems: Implementing 360-degree feedback systems allows managers to receive input from their peers, subordinates, and superiors. This holistic view of their performance can help them identify blind spots and areas for improvement. HR teams can then work with managers to address these issues through targeted coaching and development plans.
- Promoting a Culture of Open Communication: HR should encourage and facilitate open communication within the organization. This can be achieved by establishing regular check-ins, town hall meetings, and anonymous feedback channels where employees can voice their concerns without fear of retaliation. Managers should be trained to actively listen and respond constructively to employee feedback, fostering a culture of transparency and trust.
- Creating Clear Career Pathways: To address the issue of career stagnation, HR teams should work with managers to create clear career pathways for employees. This includes identifying potential opportunities for advancement, offering mentorship programs, and supporting further education and training. When employees see a future within the organization, they are more likely to stay and contribute to its success.
The correlation between poor management and high employee turnover is undeniable. While data from Western countries like the United States may not fully reflect the African context, the underlying principles remain relevant. In Kenya and other African nations, where the workforce is increasingly vocal about the need for good governance and leadership, addressing the root causes of employee dissatisfaction is essential. By recognizing the key behaviours that drive employees to quit and implementing strategic HR interventions, organizations can create a more stable, motivated, and productive workforce. This, in turn, will enhance organizational performance and contribute to the broader goals of economic development and social stability in the region.
Author
Dr. Gilbert A. Ang’ana is a Leadership, Governance, and Policy Consultant and Advisor. He is the CEO of Accent Leadership Group whose purpose is to enable leaders to influence beyond positional authority. He is also a Policy Leader Fellow at the European University Institute and an Adjunct Faculty at ACT University, Rwanda.




